Thursday, September 24, 2020

[1] A Summary of the History of Christianity: A Paradigm Shift Approach (Part 1)


A Summary of the History of Christianity (by Hans Küng)

(with annotations and revisions done by Julius-Kei Kato)

Part I - the Original Paradigm (#1) : Jesus Christ - Earliest Christianity - the Christian Scriptures 

We will refer to sub-divisions of this article by the section numbers within square brackets (e.g. [1]).

Resources:

Original Link to this Summary (in the public domain / accessed 2020-09-20): https://www.global-ethic-now.de/gen-eng/0b_weltethos-und-religionen/0b-01-02-christentum/0b-01-0201-jesus.php

Paradigm Shifts in Christianity (a one-page visual diagram) https://www.global-ethic-now.de/gen-eng/0b_weltethos-und-religionen/0b-pdf/paradigm-shifts-christianity.pdf

(HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!) Excellent survey by Bishop Richard Holloway of the six major paradigms in Christian history He also has a section at the beginning explaining paradigms and "paradigm shifts." HERE


[1]  Jesus of Nazareth--considered by his disciples as “the Christ” (the Chosen Messiah)

         Place of birth: Bethlehem or Nazareth in Galilee. He grew up in Nazareth. (Historically speaking, ‘grew up in Nazareth’ is a more secure piece of data)

         Year of birth: not after 4 BC, if Jesus was born under King Herod (27–4 BC).

         First public appearance: around the 15th year of Emperor Tiberius (27/28 or 28/29 AD), when he was baptized by John the Baptist.

         Public Life: as a wandering preacher and teacher in the region between Capernaum on the Sea of Galilee and Jerusalem – for a short time (some months?), at best not more than three years, during which time he gathered around himself a circle of disciples.

         Year of Death: He was crucified when he was perhaps in his early 30s, most probably around 30 AD, under Pontius Pilatus (26–30). The exact date cannot be determined.

Christianity takes its name from Jesus of Nazareth who was called by his followers “(the) Christ” (Heb. Moshiach / Gk. christos) meaning “the anointed one.”

Jesus is not a mythical person. His history is situated in Palestine, a province of the Roman empire at the time. He had a short public ministry and then crucified under Rome for political provocation and alleged blasphemy.

 

[2.1] The Historical Life and Ministry of Jesus of Nazareth

Jesus of Nazareth was a Jew from the peasant class who proclaimed the coming of the Kingdom of God

He lived at a time when many people believed that God was going to let his “kingdom” come.

·         God’s will—he proclaimed—is for people to love God and their neighbour (indeed even their enemies! Matthew 5:44) as they love themselves.

·         Jesus practiced solidarity with everyone who cared to listen and come to his gatherings. He prioritized the disadvantaged, e.g., the poor and the marginalized.

·         The gospels record that he performed many healing actions on behalf of the sick.

·         He sometimes relativized certain Jewish religious laws when he thought that some greater value was at stake, emphasizing that the Law was for the sake of the person and not vice versa.

·         He prophetically provoked the Temple-establishment (the priests, the Sadducee party) and their business interests in the Temple (seen in the ‘purging of the Temple’ incident)

·         He publicly confronted the religious leadership (who were Jews) and the political authorities (who were Romans).

·         For this he was tried and sentenced to death on the cross.

After his death, his disciples had encounters with him that convinced them that he had been raised by God from the dead. This easter faith and proclamation that “Christ has been risen” became the foundation of Christian faith.

 

[2.2] Jesus Christ – Human and Divine  (this part by JK Kato)

One official doctrine (teaching) regarding Jesus in Christianity is that He is both human and divine. This is the result of decisions made in several important early church councils (particularly, Nicea, Constantinople, and Chalcedon [see below]) in which it was decided that, at the official level, Jesus Christ is to be believed by Christians as “one in essence with the Father” (hence, divine), and “one person having two natures—human and divine.”

It is important though to see how the thinking about Jesus evolved over time as a historical process. We can identify several stages:

  1. ENCOUNTER: When Jesus began his public life, people perceived him first and foremost as some sort of charismatic “Rabbi” (teacher) who taught, healed, and shared fellowship with people, especially the disadvantaged.
  2. MESSIAH? As time went on, some of his followers began to believe that this charismatic rabbi was the MESSIAH who many Jews at the time were waiting for—the one who was going to realize the reign of God in their midst. Jesus also probably thought so about himself. (Note that “Messiah” was NOT EQUAL to “God” in Jesus’ historical context)
  3. POST-RESURRECTION: After Jesus’ death, the resurrection experience made the disciples identify Jesus more and more closely with YHWH, giving him exalted titles: Lord, Son of God, Saviour, Lamb of God, Prince of Peace, etc.
  4. JESUS’ DIVINITY - This process of Jesus becoming more exalted in the thinking of Christians ultimately led (300+ years later) to a radically close identification between God ("YHWH" in the Old Testament) and Jesus as expressed in the faith-statement: Jesus is also divine  (i.e., that Jesus is “God the Son,” “God incarnate,” “the Second Person of the Holy Trinity,” etc. / aka the "deification" of Jesus). This identification happened over a period of time and was made correct and required (“orthodox”) belief only in the 300s of the Common Era or AD. Note that this deification of Jesus Christ is the unique characteristic of Christianity. It is what divides it from Judaism and Islam although the three religions are monotheistic. Christianity claims that it worships ONE God in three persons (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit).
  5. The roots of this belief in Jesus having some sort of divinity are already found in the New Testament – most notably, in the gospel of John.

For a more detailed presentation of related points, see my article “Did Jesus Claim that He Was God?” in: http://www.catholica.com.au/gc4/jkk/016_jkk_240419.php

 

[3] The Earliest Christian Communities

Christianity spread in all directions from its place of origin in Roman-occupied Palestine. Some accounts of earliest Christianity’s growth are more well-documented than others. In the New Testament, the focus is on the westward expansion of the early Christian movements (from Palestine to Rome). What began as a rural movement in Palestine became predominantly an urban movement. Paul, the apostle, was particularly instrumental in making the Jesus movement a more gentile-friendly one. One early crucial problem that arose was the following:  

Controversy among the first Christians: Must Non-Jews (“gentiles” “pagans”), when they become Christians, observe the Jewish Law (Halachah), i.e., circumcision, holy days, the Sabbath, dietary rules, purity regulations? There even seemed to be conflict about this between the leading apostles, Peter and Paul ad documented in the New Testament.

Peter
“But when Cephas (= Peter) came to Antioch I opposed him to his face, because he stood self-condemned; for until certain people came from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles; but after they came, he drew back and kept himself separate, for fear of the circumcision faction. And the other Jews joined him in this hypocrisy.” (Gal. 2.11–13)

Paul
“But when I saw that they were not acting consistently with the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas (= Peter) before them all, ‘If you, though a Jew, live like a Gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews? We ourselves are Jews by birth and not Gentile sinners, yet we know that a person is justified not by the works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ. And we have come to believe in Christ Jesus, so that we might be justified by faith in Christ, and not by doing the works of the law, because no one will be justified by the works of the law’.” (Gal. 2.14–16)

Paul undertook extensive missionary journeys in the Greek-speaking world.

The Second Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed by the Romans in 70 CE. Jerusalem was further destroyed in 135 CE and the Jewish Christians were dispersed.

Greek speaking gentile Christianity came to become the dominant form of Christianity.

The Christian communities gradually developed a hierarchical structure with bishops, priests, and deacons (from the 100s [the second century] onwards)

   

[4]  Christian Scriptures (Writings)

The early Christians took over the Jewish Bible in its Greek form (called the Septuagint), which contained certain books not included in the Hebrew-language TANAK (Jewish Scriptures)

         The Christians called it the “Old Testament”, distinguishing it from the “New Testament” consisting of:

         four narratives of Jesus’ teaching and ministry (called “Gospels”),

         an account of the apostles’ ministry (The Acts of the Apostles)

         21 letters written by or attributed to Paul and other apostles,

         an apocalyptic book of prophesy (Revelation)

All of them were written between 45 and ca. 140 AD. Christians regard these writings as being inspired by God and therefore setting the norm for all subsequent Christian teaching and practice.
Only much later did the notion of a “literal inerrancy” take form.

See also: https://www.global-ethic-now.de/gen-eng/0b_weltethos-und-religionen/0b-pdf/christian_bible.pdf

Go to Part 2



No comments:

Post a Comment